Evaluation of Los Angeles County GAIN Program, 1997-2000

The Evaluation of Los Angeles Jobs-First GAIN project evaluated the results of changing Los Angeles' Greater Avenues to Independence (GAIN) program, a human resource focused welfare-to-work program into Los Angeles Jobs-First GAIN, a labor force attachment strategy. Some of the most important changes included: (1) strengthening the job club and instructing case managers to make immediate job activities referrals to almost all clients;(2) locating job developers in all GAIN offices; (3) establishing goals and performance-based contracts to reinforce the Work First message within the GAIN program structure; (4) changing program guidelines, instructions and staff training to communicate clearly to clients the central importance of finding employment; (5) informing enrollees that with liberal earnings disregards, even minimum wage jobs are financially advantageous.

The major research hypotheses for the impact evaluation were that: (1) it is possible to convert a large, diverse, mature education-focused welfare-to-work program to a Work First program; (2) the new program would produce earnings and recipiency changes of greater magnitude the original program; (3) the new program would produce earnings increases and welfare reductions with much smaller expenditures per enrollee than its predecessor; (4) having profited by experience, Jobs-First GAIN would produce equal or better results than previously evaluated Work First programs. Several additional hypotheses were provided in the context of TANF implementation: (5) Jobs-First GAIN could effectively operate on a large scale, serving a diverse welfare population; (6) the program would speedily move many recipients into jobs thereby minimizing the number who reach the TANF time limit unemployed; (7) the programs economies of scale would achieve large savings to government budgets.

The evaluation consisted of an implementation/process study, an impact study and a cost-benefit study. The methodology included a rigorous random assignment design. Data collection was primarily from administrative records, with a two-year survey of approximately 250 experimental and control group cases.

Related Resources

As welfare rolls have gone down in recent years, welfare recipients have become increasingly concentrated in…

In 1993, administrators of the Los Angeles County Department of Public Social Services (DPSS) began a total…