Parents’ Reasons for Searching for Child Care and Early Education: Findings from the 2019 National Survey of Early Care and Education

Publication Date: April 9, 2024
Parents’ Reasons for Searching for Child Care and Early Education: Findings from the 2019 National Survey of Early Care and Education

Download Brief

Download PDF (2,145.85 KB)
  • File Size: 2,145.85 KB
  • Pages: 14
  • Published: 2024

Introduction

Research Questions

  1. How many households searched for CCEE in the past 24 months?
  2. What were the main reasons parents searched for CCEE in 2019?
  3. How many searches for CCEE resulted in a change of care?
  4. What were parents’ main reasons for not changing care after a CCEE search?

This snapshot provides updated findings about parents’ child care and early education (CCEE) search and decision-making using the 2019 National Survey of Early Care and Education (NSECE) Household (HH) Survey.  We present findings on (1) the prevalence of CCEE searches among household respondents, usually parents, that reported on children under age 6, (2) the reasons for CCEE searches, (3) the rate at which parents changed their care arrangement following a search, and (4) the reasons why parents ultimately did not change their care. We tested differences in CCEE search and decision-making by household income, child age, and, where sample sizes allowed, the race and ethnicity of the selected child.


To better examine CCEE decisions within the contexts of current research, we utilize a multi-dimensional definition of CCEE access offered by the Access Guidebook to categorize parents’ reasons for looking for CCEE and reasons for not changing their care arrangement. This definition identifies equitable CCEE access as a process that requires only reasonable effort for households to find CCEE that is affordable, supports child development, and meets parents’ needs.


Importantly, no one dimension is a more preferred or valuable reason for engaging in a CCEE search than any other; comparisons are examined to better understand the reasons why parents seek CCEE and how supports and services might be better tailored to meet their needs.
 

Purpose

Several considerations factor into parents’ search for and selection of CCEE for their children. Parents may consider their income, work or schooling schedules, cultural beliefs, CCEE preferences, and local supply of CCEE. Understanding the reasons why households search for and make decisions about CCEE, and how those reasons may vary across households, can help inform efforts to promote equitable access to CCEE. 

Key Findings and Highlights

Just over one-third of households that reported on a child under age 6 searched for CCEE in the two years prior to the 2019 NSECE. 

  • Households with higher incomes (>=200% FPL) searched for CCEE at a significantly higher rate than households with lower incomes (<200% FPL).
  • Households in which the child was Hispanic or Latino had lower CCEE search rates than households in which the child was Non-Hispanic or Latino (NH) White, NH Black or African American, or NH Asian or Asian American.
  • Households in which the child was NH multiracial had higher CCEE search rates than households in which the child was NH White and NH American Indian or Alaska Native.

Meeting parents’ needs and supporting child’s development were the two most common reasons parents reported searching for CCEE in the two years prior to the 2019 NSECE. 

  • Searching for CCEE to meet parents’ needs was especially common among parents that searched for CCEE for infants and toddlers, as well as parents with lower household incomes. 
  • Supporting child’s development was a more common reason among parents that searched for CCEE for a preschool-aged child, as well as parents with higher household incomes. 
  • Households that searched for CCEE for a NH Asian or Asian American child were more likely to cite supporting child’s development and less likely to cite meeting parents’ needs as their reason for search compared to households in which the child was NH White, NH Black or African American, NH multiracial, or Hispanic or Latino.

More than half of households that searched for CCEE changed their care arrangement following their search.

  • Households with higher incomes were more likely to change their care than those with lower incomes. 

The most common reasons parents did not enroll with a new provider were related to affordability and reasonable effort.

  • There were no significant differences in the reasons parents did not enroll with a new provider by household income, child age, or the race and ethnicity of the selected child.

Methods

To capture households’ CCEE needs, preferences, and choices, the 2019 NSECE HH Survey includes information on a randomly selected child living in each household. The data in this snapshot represent the 16,372,451 households that reported on a selected child under age 6 (i.e., 0 to <72 months, not yet in kindergarten), with a special focus on the 5,950,051 households that conducted a CCEE search for that child in the 24 months prior to survey administration.[1] We used Wald’s tests to examine how the reasons for search, rates of change in CCEE, and reasons for not changing CCEE varied by household characteristics (i.e., household income, age of selected child, and race and ethnicity of the selected child) where sample sizes allowed. We did not conduct comparisons tests on samples that were suppressed or flagged for cautious interpretation. To lower the probability of falsely identifying significant differences among many comparisons, we adjusted for multiple comparisons using the Benjamini-Hochberg procedure[2] with a false discovery rate (FDR) of 0.10.


[1] Given the limited household sample identified for the proposed research questions, sample sizes became increasingly small when disaggregating households by demographic characteristics. Estimates derived from an unweighted sample of less than 50 households are flagged for cautious interpretation. Estimates derived from an unweighted sample of less than 20 households were suppressed for reliability concerns, but not for privacy or identity disclosure concerns.

[2] Benjamini, Y., & Hochberg, Y. (1995). Controlling the false discovery rate: A practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B, 57, 289-300. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2517-6161.1995.tb02031.x

Quick Fact Images


 

Left Bar Graph: In households with children from 0 to 72 months, 30% of households earning less than 200% FPL were searching for care, compared to 42% of households at 200% or more FPL. Center Bar Graph: In households with infants/toddlers (0 to 36 months), 30% of households earning less than 200% FPL were searching for care, compared to 44% of households at 200% or more FPL. Right Bar Graph: In households with preschoolers (36 to 72 months), 29% of households earning less than 200% FPL were searching for c

 

Figure 1. Percent of households that reported on CCEE search for a child under age 6, by household income and age of child  

Source: Analysis of the 2019 NSECE HH Survey by Child Trends. 

Note: Sample includes households that reported on children under age 6, not yet in kindergarten, excluding cases in which search status was missing. FPL = federal poverty level 

 * Significant group differences passing a FDR correction threshold of 0.10  

Alt Text: Left Bar Graph: In households with children from 0 to 72 months, 30% of households earning less than 200% FPL were searching for care, compared to 42% of households at 200% or more FPL. Center Bar Graph: In households with infants/toddlers (0 to 36 months), 30% of households earning less than 200% FPL were searching for care, compared to 44% of households at 200% or more FPL. Right Bar Graph: In households with preschoolers (36 to 72 months), 29% of households earning less than 200% FPL were searching for care, compared to 41% of households at 200% or more FPL. 

This pie graph shows that the main reason that parents search for care is to meet their needs (68%). Supporting their child’s development was the second most common reason, at 27 percent. Affordability and “other” were the least common reasons, at 3 percent each.

Figure 3. Main reason households reported searching for CCEE, categorized into the Access Guidebook dimensions 

Source: Analysis of the 2019 NSECE HH Survey by Child Trends. 

Note: Sample includes households that reported on children under age 6, not yet in kindergarten, and recently searched for CCEE, excluding cases in which the reason for search was missing. Other reasons include responses such as, “wanted to give provider relief” or, “child wanted to go to program.” See Appendix A, Table A1 for a full listing of responses coded into each dimension.  

Alt Text: This pie graph shows that the main reason that parents search for care is to meet their needs (68%). Supporting their child’s development was the second most common reason, at 27 percent. Affordability and “other” were the least common reasons, at 3 percent each.  

Glossary

Child care and early education (CCEE):
Refers to caregiving and educational services for children from birth to age 13. CCEE includes center- and home-based settings for infants, toddlers, preschool- and school-aged children. CCEE refers to services for a larger age group than early care and education.
CCEE Access:
Parents, with reasonable effort and affordabilty, can enroll their child in an arrangement that supports the child’s development and meets the parents’ needs.
Parents searching for care for infants and toddlers:
Parents reporting on their search for care for a child who was 0 to <36 months at the time of the survey.
Parents searching for care for preschool-aged children:
Parents reporting on their search for care for a child who was 36 to <72 months, not yet in kindergarten, at the time of the survey.
Race and ethnicity:
Respondent-reported race and ethnicity of the selected child, including: Non-Hispanic or Latino (NH) White; NH Black or African American; NH Asian or Asian American; NH Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander; NH American Indian or Alaska Native; NH Multiracial, NH another racial category not collected; and Hispanic or Latino (any race).